news
New York — Times' Reader-Cartoon Roundup Discloses No Entry Count

The New York Times published a reader-submission feature titled "In the Style of P.C. Vey: The Funniest Reader Cartoons We Received," according to the Google News listing of the story. The listing that this desk could access carries a headline and a source line and nothing else — no entry count, no judging process, no editor's name.
What Does the Times' Cartoon Feature Actually Say?
The premise is simple: readers submit cartoons in the style of New Yorker contributor P.C. Vey, and the Times picks the funniest ones for a roundup, per the headline on the Google News aggregation. That is the entirety of what is verifiable from the material available to this desk. The aggregator did not surface a byline, a submission window, or a word count for the underlying Times piece. Readers clicking through may find more detail on the Times' own site; this review is limited to what the feed actually delivered.
What Number Is Missing From the Piece?
Two figures that a rigorous accountability piece would normally carry are absent from everything this desk was given:
- Entries disclosed: 0. No count of how many readers submitted cartoons appears in the headline or the snippet.
- Judges or editors named: 0. No selection panel, cartoon editor, or Vey himself is credited with picking winners in the material reviewed.
A missing number is not proof of malpractice. It is proof of an unlabeled selection process — the Times decided what counts as "funniest" without telling the audience who decided or from how large a pool.
Why Does a Missing Count Matter for the Times?
The Times holds itself to a published accuracy standard. A companion piece from this desk, "Crafting Corrections: Ensuring Accuracy and Accountability," lays out the case that newsroom credibility rests on showing readers how conclusions were reached, not just announcing them. A cartoon roundup is low stakes compared with a correction on a news story. But the same instinct — tell the reader the basis for a judgment — applies whether the judgment is "this claim is false" or "this cartoon is the funniest one we got." The Times asks readers to trust an editorial call either way. Neither claim, in the material reviewed here, comes with its receipts.
Does This Fit a Pattern Elsewhere in Current Coverage?
Contrast the cartoon feature with a separate report from this outlet on a San Francisco airport contractor sharing facial data with federal agencies. That story is not a Times piece, and the comparison is not an apples-to-apples one. But it illustrates the baseline this desk applies to accountability journalism generally: name the contractor, name the agency, state what data moved and under what authority. A reader-cartoon roundup does not need that level of sourcing to be enjoyable. It does need enough disclosure that "funniest" reads as a described editorial choice rather than an assertion.
What Should Readers Watch For Next?
If the Times' full text — unavailable through the aggregator link reviewed for this piece — does include an entry count, a judging credit, or a note on how "funniest" was determined, that information did not travel with the headline into the Google News feed. Readers who want the fuller picture should go to the original Times page directly rather than rely on a headline alone. The practical lesson is not about cartoons. It is that even a soft feature invites the same question this desk asks of hard news: what is the sourced basis for the claim in the headline. For "the funniest reader cartoons we received," that basis has not yet surfaced in what was reviewed.
Nothing here alleges the Times fabricated anything. The complaint is narrower: a selection was presented without the selection criteria, and the only number attached to the piece, as far as this desk can verify, is zero.
Questions
Did the New York Times disclose how many readers submitted cartoons for the P.C. Vey-style feature?
Not in the material reviewed by this desk. The Google News listing of the Times piece included no entry count.
Who judged the cartoons in the Times' roundup?
No judging panel or editor was named in the headline or snippet available to this desk at the time of review.