sports

New York Times Story on Dejounte Murray Posts Lacks Detail

Opinion

· sports, news

Basketball player checking a smartphone courtside with a blurred social media interface visible on screen
Photo by Ron Lach / Pexels · source

The New York Times reports that Dejounte Murray responded to critical Pelicans fans with profane social media posts, according to the paper's own account. What those posts say, and what the fans said that drew the response, does not appear in the headline or the summary available to readers scanning the story on an aggregator.

What did Murray actually post?

The available account does not quote a single sentence from Murray. "Profane" is the only adjective doing the work of describing what a veteran NBA guard wrote to his own fan base. Readers are told a reaction happened. They are not shown it.

Why does the word "profane" do so much work?

Sports desks routinely use "profane" as a substitute for a direct quote, often because the underlying posts have been deleted or because editors prefer not to run obscenities verbatim. That is a defensible house-style call. But it leaves the reader dependent entirely on the outlet's characterization, with no screenshot, no archived link, and no second source to check the framing against.

What is missing from the report?

Three basic facts are absent from the headline-level account: which fans, what they posted that triggered Murray, and when the exchange happened relative to a Pelicans game or news event. A story built around a single athlete's reaction to unnamed critics, without identifying the criticism itself, asks readers to trust the characterization rather than evaluate the exchange.

How should readers verify a story like this?

The standard playbook is simple: find the original posts, check timestamps, and see whether the outlet linked to them. Pinewood Creations' own corrections policy argues that accountability starts with showing the material a story is built on, not summarizing it from a distance. That standard applies here too.

What's next for coverage of this story

  • Whether the Times or another outlet publishes the actual text of Murray's posts, with timestamps.
  • Whether the Pelicans or the NBA comment on the exchange.
  • Whether Murray addresses the posts himself, on or off the platform where they appeared.
  • Whether other outlets corroborate the fan criticism that reportedly prompted the response.

None of that is in evidence yet. Until it is, the story is a headline describing a reaction to an argument nobody outside the participants has seen.

Does this follow a pattern?

The Murray item is not unique in form. Athlete-versus-fan posts are a recurring sports-desk genre precisely because they generate engagement without requiring the reporting labor of identifying sources, confirming timestamps, or securing comment from the team or league. The structure is replicable: name the athlete, assert a reaction, withhold the provocation. Readers looking at the Times account have no way to distinguish a genuinely newsworthy blowup from a routine social-media skirmish amplified into a headline.

Until the posts themselves surface, with timestamps and the fan criticism that preceded them, this remains a story about a reaction, not a story about what happened.

Disclosure. This article may include affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Legal entity: Pinewood Creations LLC. Smorgi Apps appears only as an affiliate partner in house slots — not as publisher or owner. See our affiliate disclosure.

Questions

What did Dejounte Murray actually say to Pelicans fans?

The available New York Times account describes the posts only as profane; it does not quote their text or link to the original posts.

What did the Pelicans fans say that prompted the response?

The sourcing provided does not identify the specific fan criticism Murray was responding to.

Sources

More from The Failing New York Times

Briefing

Top stories from the HTT News network by email. Free. No noise.

More from our network