news

News-Herald Column on Right-Left Criticism Lacks Specifics

Opinion

· news, politics

Newspaper opinion page with a magnifying glass over a column headline
Illustration

A column headlined "Misunderstanding criticism on the Right and Left" ran on thenewsherald.com this week, promising to explain why partisans on both sides read criticism of their side in bad faith. What that argument actually says cannot be checked here. The link available through Google News redirects to the outlet's own page, and no excerpt, quote, or named example accompanied the headline in the material reviewed for this piece.

What does the column actually claim?

That is the first problem. A headline promising to diagnose "misunderstanding" on both the right and the left is, by construction, a symmetry claim — it asserts that two different political coalitions make the same category of error. Symmetry claims are empirical claims. They require examples: which criticism, misunderstood by whom, and how. None of that is visible in the source material tied to this item. Readers who saw only the headline circulating on social platforms or news aggregators have no way to evaluate whether the column backs its framing with specific incidents or simply asserts balance as a rhetorical device.

Why does "both sides" framing need extra scrutiny?

Columns built around symmetrical blame are common in opinion sections because they read as fair-minded by default. But fairness in form is not the same as accuracy in substance. A piece that says the right misunderstands criticism one way and the left misunderstands it another way needs to show the same rigor on each side — same number of examples, same sourcing, same specificity — or the framing does rhetorical work the reporting hasn't earned. That standard applies regardless of which newsroom publishes the column.

What does this outlet's own corrections process say about accountability?

A related piece on accuracy standards, Crafting Corrections: Ensuring Accuracy and Accountability, lays out the baseline this desk holds itself to: contested and numerical claims need a source in the same sentence they appear, and claims that cannot be corroborated should produce a narrower story, not a confident one. That standard is the reason this item stops short of characterizing the News-Herald column's argument beyond its headline.

What should readers do with a headline like this?

Ask for the receipts before sharing. A column asserting that both political coalitions misread criticism should name the criticism, name the misreading, and show the pattern more than once per side. Absent that, the headline functions as a vibe, not a finding. Readers can follow the original item on Google News and decide for themselves whether the piece meets that bar — this desk simply cannot certify it on the information available.

Disclosure. This article may include affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Legal entity: Pinewood Creations LLC. Smorgi Apps appears only as an affiliate partner in house slots — not as publisher or owner. See our affiliate disclosure.

Questions

Did this piece review the full text of the News-Herald column?

No. Only the headline and Google News listing were available in the source material used for this piece; the column's full argument was not accessible for review.

Why does a 'both sides' headline draw extra scrutiny?

Because it makes a symmetry claim about two different political coalitions, which requires specific, comparable examples on each side to be verified rather than simply asserted.

Sources

More from The Failing New York Times

Briefing

Top stories from the HTT News network by email. Free. No noise.

More from our network